| Category | Jeff | Kyle | Brett Nolan | Correct #/3 | |
| Worst Picture JACK & JILL |
NO | YES | NO | 1 | |
| Worst Actor Adam Sandler (JACK & JILL and JUST GO WITH IT) |
NO | YES | NO | 1 | |
| Worst Actress Adam Sandler (As Jill) (JACK & JILL) |
YES | YES | YES | 3 | |
| Worst Supporting Actor Al Pacino (As Al Pacino) (JACK & JILL) |
NO | NO | NO | 0 | |
| Worst Supporting Actress David Spade (As Monica) (JACK & JILL) |
NO | NO | YES | 1 | |
| Worst Screen Ensemble The Entire Cast of JACK & JILL |
NO | YES | NO | 1 | |
| Worst Director Dennis Dugan (JACK & JILL and JUST GO WITH IT) |
NO | YES | NO | 1 | |
| Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel JACK & JILL (Remake/Rip-Off of Ed Woods' GLEN OR GLENDA) |
NO | YES | NO | 1 | |
| Category | Jeff | Kyle | Brett Nolan | Correct #/3 | |
| Worst Screen Couple Adam Sandler and EITHER Katie Holmes, Al Pacino OR Adam Sandler / JACK & JILL |
YES | YES | YES | 3 | |
| Worst Screenplay JACK & JILL (Screenplay by Steve Koren & Adam Sandler, Story by Ben Zook) |
NO | YES | NO | 1 | |
| TOTALS: (10/10) | 2 | 8 | 3 | ||
| Category | Jeff | Kyle | Brett Nolan | ||